What Are Index Funds and How Do They Beat Active Fund Managers?

 

What Are Index Funds and How Do They Beat Active Fund Managers?

For investment in fixed income investments visit:-

Understanding basics of Fixed income investments

ESG Investing:-

Why ESG Investing is gaining Popularity

Introduction

Investors in India often face a crucial decision: should they invest in actively managed mutual funds or opt for index funds? Index funds, which track market indices like the Nifty 50 or Sensex, have gained popularity due to their lower costs and consistent performance over the long term. But how do these funds compare to actively managed ones? More importantly, how do they often outperform active fund managers? Let's explore.

What Are Index Funds?

Index funds are mutual funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) designed to replicate the performance of a specific market index. Instead of being actively managed by a fund manager, they follow a passive investment strategy, holding all or most of the securities in the index they track.

Key Characteristics of Index Funds:

• Passive Management: No frequent buying and selling of stocks.
• Lower Expense Ratio: Due to minimal fund manager involvement.
• Market Performance Replication: Returns mirror those of the index.
• Diversification: Spreads risk across multiple stocks in the index.

Popular Index Funds in India 

1.       UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund

2.       ICICI Prudential Nifty Next 50 Index Fund 

3.       HDFC Sensex Index Fund

How Index Funds Outperform Active Fund Managers

Many investors believe that active fund managers, with their research and expertise, should consistently outperform the market. However, data shows that most actively managed funds fail to beat their benchmarks over the long term. Here’s why:

1. Lower Costs and Expense Ratios

One of the biggest advantages of index funds is their low expense ratio. Actively managed funds charge higher fees (typically 1.5%–2.5% in India) due to research, stock selection, and trading costs. In contrast, index funds have expense ratios as low as 0.2%–0.5%, which translates into higher net returns for investors over time.

Why does this matter? Over time, even a small difference in fees can have a massive impact on your returns. For instance, if you invest ₹10,00,000 in an active fund with a 1.5% expense ratio and another ₹10,00,000 in an index fund with a 0.2% expense ratio, assuming both funds return 10% annually before fees, the difference in fees alone could cost you over ₹5,00,000 in lost returns over 20 years.

2. Consistent Market Returns

Active fund managers attempt to beat the market, but only a small percentage succeed consistently. Many fund managers underperform due to:

• Market timing mistakes.
• High portfolio turnover leading to increased costs.
• Human bias and decision-making inefficiencies.

According to the SPIVA India Scorecard, over 80% of actively managed large-cap funds in India underperformed the S&P BSE 100 index over a 10-year period. This is where index funds shine—they don’t try to beat the market; they match it. By doing so, they provide consistent, predictable returns that often surpass those of actively managed funds, especially after accounting for fees.

On the other hand, index funds eliminate the risk of poor stock selection by simply tracking the broader market.

3. Minimal Trading and Tax Efficiency

Frequent trading in active funds generates short-term capital gains, leading to higher tax liabilities for investors. Since index funds follow a buy-and-hold strategy, they trigger fewer taxable events, making them more tax-efficient.

4. Long-Term Performance Advantage

A study of mutual funds in India over 10+ years shows that 80% of actively managed large-cap funds underperform the Nifty 50 index. The reason? Market efficiency ensures that stock prices reflect all available information, making it difficult for managers to consistently gain an edge.

Real-Life Performance: Nifty 50 vs. Active Funds

Let’s look at some numbers to illustrate the power of index funds in India. Over the past decade, the Nifty 50 has delivered an average annual return of around 12-14%. During the same period, many actively managed large-cap funds struggled to consistently beat this benchmark after accounting for fees.

For instance, consider the performance of the UTI Nifty Index Fund, one of India’s oldest index funds. From its inception in 2000 to 2023, it has closely tracked the Nifty 50, delivering returns that mirror the index’s growth. In contrast, several actively managed funds have seen periods of underperformance, especially during market downturns.

Here’s a quick comparison of returns (as of 2023, hypothetical for illustrative purposes):

Nifty 50 Index Fund (after fees): 12.5% annual return

Average Actively Managed Large-Cap Fund (after fees): 10.8% annual return

Over 20 years, this difference in returns could mean lakhs of rupees in additional wealth for index fund investors.

 

Case Study: The Long-Term Investor

Meet Rajesh, a 35-year-old IT professional from Bangalore. In 2010, Rajesh invested ₹5,00,000 in a Nifty 50 index fund and another ₹5,00,000 in a popular actively managed large-cap fund. Fast forward to 2023, his index fund investment has grown to approximately ₹18,00,000, while his active fund investment, after fees, is worth around ₹16,50,000. The difference? Lower fees and consistent market returns.

Rajesh’s story is not unique. Many Indian investors have found that index funds, with their passive approach, often yield better long-term results than trying to pick winning stocks or funds. For Rajesh, the simplicity of index funds also meant less stress—no need to constantly monitor fund manager performance or worry about market timing.

Criteria	Index Funds	Active Funds
Management Style	Passive (tracks an index)	Active (fund manager picks stocks)
Expense Ratio	Low (0.1% - 0.5%)	High (1% - 2%)
Performance	Matches the market	Aims to beat the market (but often doesn’t)
Risk	Market risk (diversified)	Market risk + manager risk
Best For	Long-term investors seeking steady growth	Investors willing to take higher risks for potentially higher returns
Transparency	High (holdings mirror the index)	Varies (depends on fund manager’s strategy)

 

Choosing the Right Index Fund in India

For Indian investors, selecting the right index fund depends on factors like tracking error, expense ratio, and liquidity. Here are some popular choices:

Index Fund	Underlying Index	Expense Ratio
UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund	Nifty 50	0.2%
HDFC Index Sensex Fund	Sensex	0.3%
ICICI Prudential Nifty Next 50 Index Fund	Nifty Next 50	0.4%

 

Debunking Myths about Index Funds 

 

Myth 1: “Index Funds Are Only for Beginners” 

Even seasoned investors like John Bogle, founder of Vanguard, championed index funds for their reliability. 

 

Myth 2: “Active Funds Always Beat the Market” 

Data tells a different story: Over 15 years, 80% of US active funds underperform indices. India mirrors this trend. 

 

FAQs

1. Are index funds better than actively managed funds?

Over the long term, index funds generally outperform actively managed funds due to lower costs and market efficiency.

2. Do index funds provide dividends?

Yes, some index funds distribute dividends if the underlying companies pay dividends.

3. Are index funds safe investments?

While index funds eliminate fund manager risk, they still carry market risk and fluctuate based on index performance.

4. How can I invest in index funds in India?

You can invest through mutual fund platforms, brokers, or directly via AMCs.

5. What is tracking error in index funds?

Tracking error measures the difference between the index fund's returns and the actual index. Lower tracking error is preferable.

Conclusion

Index funds offer Indian investors a cost-effective, diversified, and efficient way to build wealth over time. While active fund managers may outperform occasionally, data suggests that passive investing via index funds remains the better choice for long-term financial growth.

Disclaimer:

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Please consult with a SEBI-registered financial advisor before making any investment decisions.