Variable Frequency Drive (VFD) disadvantages

Disadvantages of Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs)

While Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) offer many benefits such as energy savings, soft starting, and precise speed control, they also come with certain limitations that must be considered before selecting them for industrial applications. Below are the key disadvantages of VFDs:

---

1. High Initial Cost

• VFDs are more expensive compared to traditional motor starters such as DOL (Direct-On-Line) and Star-Delta.

• The initial investment often discourages smaller plants from adopting VFDs, despite the long-term energy savings.

• Payback period generally ranges between 1 to 2.5 years, depending on load type, operating hours, and energy tariffs.

---

2. Maintenance & Troubleshooting Require Specialized Skills

• Traditional starters are simple and inexpensive to maintain; failures can usually be identified by basic inspection.

• VFDs, being solid-state electronic devices, require:

  • Special test equipment

  • Skilled and trained personnel for troubleshooting

  • Costly spare parts

• Repairs are not straightforward, and often entire modules need replacement.

---

3. Harmonics and Additional Heating in Motors

• The output waveform of a VFD is not perfectly sinusoidal; instead, it contains harmonics.

• These harmonics:

  • Cause additional heating (typically 5–8% higher than with sinusoidal supply).

  • Increase motor losses and reduce efficiency.

• Solution: Use inverter-duty (Class F insulated) motors that can withstand harmonic stresses and higher heating.

---

4. Risk of Motor Overheating at Low Speeds

• In constant torque applications, motors draw the same current regardless of speed.

• When VFD reduces motor frequency (and hence speed):

  • Cooling fan speed decreases.

  • Heat dissipation reduces.

  • Motor may overheat at very low speeds.

• Example:

  • A motor with Class B insulation can safely run down to ~50% speed under full load without overheating.

  • With Class F insulation, the limit extends to ~20% speed.

• Derating of both motor and VFD is required for continuous operation at very low speeds.

---

Key Takeaway

While VFDs are excellent for energy efficiency and speed control, engineers must weigh their high initial cost, maintenance complexity, harmonic effects, and low-speed overheating issues against the operational benefits. In most cases, selecting an inverter-duty motor along with proper derating ensures reliable long-term performance.

---